© 2002 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Highlights of this issue |
Highlights of this issue
DRUGS, PSYCHOPATHOLOGY AND OFFENDING
Exploring the relationship between psychosis and drug dependence in prisoners, Farrell et al (pp. 393–398) found the prevalence of psychosis to be more than 20 times that reported in the general population. Severe dependence on cannabis and psychostimulants were associated with the highest risk of psychosis. The authors emphasise the importance of warning vulnerable individuals of the detrimental effects of cocaine in particular. In a long-term follow-up of patients discharged from special (high-security) hospitals, Jamieson & Taylor (pp. 399–405) found that 20% of individuals never return to open community living. Mental illness, old age and being male, rather than offending history, tended to prevent this.
CHRONIC EFFECTS OF PSYCHIATRIC DISORDER
Difficult-to-place long-stay patients will not disappear with the closure of psychiatric hospitals, since a large proportion of them are new long-stay. As part of the TAPS Project, Trieman & Leff (pp. 428–432) followed 72 long-stay difficult-to-place patients for 5 years. Slow-stream rehabilitation in specialised facilities produced sufficient improvement in over 40% to enable moves to community homes. They conclude that the consequent saving of money in the long term justifies the investment in such rehabilitation units. Despite the introduction of atypical antipsychotic drugs, movement disorders remain significant problems for patients. Halliday et al (pp. 422–427) measured the prevalence of common movement disorders in 136 patients with psychosis in Scotland and found the prevalence of tardive dyskinesia to have doubled in 20 years; 43% had probable tardive dyskinesia, 35% had parkinsonism and akathisia was found in 15%.
HOME TREATMENT NOT BETTER IN USA?
North American studies of home treatment for mental disorders find greater reductions in hospitalisation than European ones. Burns et al (pp. 375–382), in a meta-analysis, explore the possible explanations for this discrepancy between continents. Results suggest that American patients in the experimental groups spend no less time in hospital than those in the European experimental groups but that the difference lies in the control groups with which they are compared. It is suggested that the control services in Europe may be closer to their experimental counterparts, possibly in their emphasis on visiting patients at home.
OUTCOME OF ADHD IN GIRLS
The adult outcome of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in girls has never been studied. Using the Danish Psychiatric Central Register, Dalsgaard et al (pp. 416–421) traced the adult psychiatric status of 208 children who had been admitted and treated with stimulants between the ages of 4 and 15. Overall, 23% had an adult psychiatric admission, with girls at greater risk than boys. Girls with ADHD and conduct problems had a very high risk of adult psychiatric admission, the most common adult diagnoses being personality and mood disorders.
DEPRESSION, COGNITIVE DECLINE AND THE CEREBELLUM
Depressive symptoms are associated with cognitive decline in the elderly, but the temporal relationship remains unclear. Paterniti et al (pp. 406–410), in a longitudinal study, found that initially high levels of depressive symptoms predicted cognitive decline at 4-year follow-up in an elderly population of 1003 people with good cognitive functioning at recruitment. Cognitive decline was more likely in those reporting persistent rather than episodic depression. Smith et al (pp. 411–415), in a functional magnetic resonance imaging study, report that abnormal cerebellar function could be a marker of vulnerability to recurrent depression.
NEURODEVELOPMENT AND SCHIZOPHRENIA
Neurological soft signs are common in people with schizophrenia and appear to have a developmental origin which could result from physical illness in childhood. Leask et al (pp. 387–392) explore this in a longitudinal study and find that, although some childhood illnesses are associated with increased rates of neurological soft signs, there are few consistent associations between childhood illness and adult psychiatric disorders. Cotter & Pariante (pp. 363–365) review the evidence for and against the neurodevelopmental hypothesis of schizophrenia. They argue that it alone is insufficient to explain the unfolding neuroanatomy of the disorder, which now seems likely to involve both early developmental and later atrophic changes.
SURVIVING DISASTER
Hull et al (pp. 433–438) assessed 36 survivors of the Piper Alpha oil platform disaster, which killed 167 men in 1988. Twenty-one per cent met the criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and development of the disorder was associated with physical injury, personal experience and survivor guilt. On a positive note, 61% reported that some good had come from the trauma, including enriched emotional relationships and financial security. Davidson (pp. 366–368), in an accompanying editorial, provides an excellent overview of the early identification, prevention and treatment of PTSD.
Related articles in BJP:
- Stress and the progression of the developmental hypothesis of schizophrenia
- DAVID COTTER and CARMINE M. PARIANTE
BJP 2002 181: 363-365.[Full Text] - Surviving disaster: what comes after the trauma?
- JONATHAN R. T. DAVIDSON
BJP 2002 181: 366-368.[Full Text] - International differences in home treatment for mental health problems: Results of a systematic review
- TOM BURNS, JOCELYN CATTY, HILARY WATT, CHRISTINE WRIGHT, MARTIN KNAPP, and JULIET HENDERSON
BJP 2002 181: 375-382.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Adult psychosis, common childhood infections and neurological soft signs in a national birth cohort
- STUART J. LEASK, D. JOHN DONE, and TIMOTHY J. CROW
BJP 2002 181: 387-392.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Psychosis and drug dependence: results from a national survey of prisoners
- M. FARRELL, A. BOYS, P. BEBBINGTON, T. BRUGHA, J. COID, R. JENKINS, G. LEWIS, H. MELTZER, J. MARSDEN, N. SINGLETON, and C. TAYLOR
BJP 2002 181: 393-398.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Mental disorder and perceived threat to the public: people who do not return to community living
- LIZ JAMIESON and PAMELA J. TAYLOR
BJP 2002 181: 399-405.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Depressive symptoms and cognitive decline in elderly people: Longitudinal study
- SABRINA PATERNITI, MARIE-HÉLÈNE VERDIER-TAILLEFER, CAROLE DUFOUIL, and ANNICK ALPÉROVITCH
BJP 2002 181: 406-410.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Cerebellar responses during anticipation of noxious stimuli in subjects recovered from depression: Functional magnetic resonance imaging study
- KATHARINE A. SMITH, ALEXANDER PLOGHAUS, PHILIP J. COWEN, JENNY M. McCLEERY, GUY M. GOODWIN, STEPHEN SMITH, IRENE TRACEY, and PAUL M. MATTHEWS
BJP 2002 181: 411-415.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Conduct problems, gender and adult psychiatric outcome of children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder
- SØREN DALSGAARD, PREBEN BO MORTENSEN, MORTEN FRYDENBERG, and PER HOVE THOMSEN
BJP 2002 181: 416-421.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Nithsdale Schizophrenia Surveys 23: movement disorders: 20-year review
- JENNIFER HALLIDAY, SUSAN FARRINGTON, SHIONA MACDONALD, TOM MacEWAN, VAL SHARKEY, and ROBIN McCREADIE
BJP 2002 181: 422-427.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Long-term outcome of long-stay psychiatric in-patients considered unsuitable to live in the community: TAPS Project 44
- NOAM TRIEMAN and JULIAN LEFF
BJP 2002 181: 428-432.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Survivors of the Piper Alpha oil platform disaster: long-term follow-up study
- ALASTAIR M. HULL, DAVID A. ALEXANDER, and SUSAN KLEIN
BJP 2002 181: 433-438.[Abstract] [Full Text]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||