Department of Environmental and Occupational Medicine, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey (UMDNJ) and Robert Wood Johnson Medical School (RWJMS), Piscataway, New Jersey, USA
Bute Medical School, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, Fife, UK
Department of Human Ecology Social Science, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey
Department of Environmental and Community Medicine, UMDNJRWJMS, Piscataway, New Jersey
School of Public Health, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina
National Center for Environmental Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia
Department of Environmental and Occupational Medicine, UMDNJRWJMS, Piscataway, New Jersey, USA
Correspondence: Dr Nancy Fiedler, UMDNJRobert Wood Johnson Medical School, 170 Frelinghuysen Road, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA. Tel: +1 732 445 0123 extn 625; e-mail: nfiedler{at}eohsi.rutgers.edu
Declaration of interest None. Funding detailed in Acknowledgements.
|
|
|---|
Aims To compare the 12-month prevalence and associated risk factors for DSM Axis I psychiatric diagnoses between random samples of Gulf War-deployed veterans and veterans of the same era not deployed to the Persian Gulf (era veterans).
Method Interview data from 967 Gulf War veterans and 784 era veterans were examined to determine current health status, medical conditions, symptoms and Axis I psychiatric disorders.Logistic regression models evaluated risk factors for psychiatric disorder.
Results Gulf War veterans had a significantly higher prevalence of psychiatric diagnoses, with twice the prevalence of anxiety disorders and depression.Lower rank, female gender and divorced or single marital status were significant independent predictors of psychiatric disorder.
Conclusions Deployment to the Gulf War is associated with a range of mental health outcomes more than 10 years after deployment.
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Questionnaire
All telephone interviews were administered using a computer-assisted
telephone interview program. Participants were asked to rate their current
health status, to report on 40 medical conditions diagnosed by a physician and
to rate the presence and severity of 60 symptoms (further details available
from the author upon request).
The overall purpose of our study was to determine the current symptoms and psychiatric disorders of Gulf War veterans. Therefore, as part of the telephone interview, participants were administered the Composite International Diagnostic Interview Short Form/Diagnostic and Statistical Manual IV (CIDISF/DSMIV; World Health Organization, 2002) to assess generalised anxiety, panic disorder, simple phobia, social phobia, agoraphobia, obsessivecompulsive disorder, major depression, alcohol dependence and drug dependence for the past 12 months. The 12-month version of the CIDI (World Health Organization, 1997) for the DSMIV (American Psychiatric Association, 1994) was used to assess post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), mania, anorexia nervosa and bulimia. Methodological studies have not been completed for all versions of the CIDI. However, reliability and validity data are available for the DSMIIIR lifetime CIDI: for example, kappa testretest (13 days) reliabilities for the lifetime CIDI range from 0.64 for bulimia to 0.84 for panic disorder (Wittchen, 1994). Furthermore, sensitivity and specificity of the CIDISF/DSMIIIR were acceptable relative to results achieved with the lifetime CIDI/DSMIIIR administered in the National Comorbidity Survey (average sensitivity 90.75, range 77.0100; average specificity 98.04, range 93.999.9; Kessler et al, 1998). The only essential difference between the DSMIIIR and DSMIV versions of the CIDISF was the added requirement that symptoms result in clinically significant distress or impairment.
Positive predictive values for the lifetime CIDI compared with the Structured Clinical Interview for DSMIIIR have been calculated for diagnosis-specific random subsamples of the National Comorbidity Survey respondents. Positive predictive values ranged from 0.21 for generalised anxiety to 0.95 for social phobia (Kessler et al, 1998). These predictive values were for lifetime rather than 12-month diagnoses, however, and thus may be somewhat lower than would be expected for 12-month diagnoses. A more recent study comparing the CIDI 12-month version with a structured clinical interview conducted by a clinician found an overall positive predictive value of 0.89 for any neurotic disorder (Jordanova et al, 2004). Owing to the infrequency of non-affective psychosis and bipolar disorder in the general population, it is difficult to achieve reliable diagnoses (Kendler et al, 1996; Kessler et al, 1997). Therefore, these diagnoses were not evaluated.
Diagnostic scoring was based on the procedures outlined for the CIDISF and CIDI 12-month version, with the exception of somatisation. Because of time constraints, a full interview for somatisation disorder was not possible. An abridged definition requiring a minimum of six symptoms for women or four symptoms for men (Escobar et al, 1987) was used to establish somatisation. If the person rated as moderate or severe any of 16 symptoms, similar to those used in the Primary Care Evaluation of Mental Disorders (PRIMEMD; Spitzer et al, 1994) to screen for somatisation (e.g. fainting, menstrual problems or abdominal pain), the symptom was counted toward a diagnosis of somatisation disorder. For each somatisation symptom reported, the probe flow procedure from the CIDI was used to rule out medical explanations. Medical explanations were reviewed, masked, by a physician (H.M.K.) for consistency with the symptom.
Thirty interviewers, experienced in social science interviews, were trained by clinicians to administer the interview and were tested individually using a set of live mock interviews. The probe flow method for the CIDI 12-month version was sequentially programmed. To ensure quality control throughout the study, portions of interviews conducted by each interviewer were covertly monitored twice per shift and 10% of the interviews were monitored in their entirety. Participants were told as a part of the informed consent that their interview could be monitored by a clinician or supervisor. Concordance on question sequence and coding was 100% for all cases monitored. The median interview length was 46.7 min (minimum 18.4 min, maximum 213.6). The interviewers were trained to recognise suicidal or homicidal intent and to alert the on-call clinical psychologist.
Procedure
The protocol and verbal consent were reviewed and approved by the
institutional review boards of Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Rutgers
University and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. In accordance
with US government requirements, a certificate of confidentiality was issued
under the authority of the Department of Health and Human Services.
Individuals selected and sent a letter describing the study were asked to
return a prepaid postcard indicating a preference of date and time to be
interviewed. Those who failed to return their postcards within 5 days were
telephoned, to enquire about their interest in the study, answer questions
and, if possible, obtain verbal consent and set up an interview time.
Participant recruitment and interviewing took place from February 2000 until
October 2001.
Statistical analyses
Chi-squared analyses (using the Statistical Package for the Social
Sciences, version 12.1 for Windows) were used to analyse participant
characteristics and to compare respondents and non-respondents. Twelve-month
prevalence of psychiatric disorders was stratified by deployment status and
gender. Separate logistic regressions to predict psychiatric diagnoses used
the demographic variables for Gulf War and era veterans listed in
Table 3. To increase the
stability of the models, participants with any one of the following anxiety
disorders were included in the combined logistic regression for anxiety:
agoraphobia, general anxiety disorder, obsessivecompulsive disorder,
panic attack, social phobia, simple phobia and PTSD. A second logistic
regression model was developed for major depression and a third for drug or
alcohol dependence. Owing to the small number of cases, logistic regression
analyses were not performed to predict mania.
|
View this table: [in a new window] | Table 3 Demographic characteristics of Gulf War veterans and era veterans |
The logistic regression analyses used to summarise these data roughly
followed the procedures of Hosmer & Lemeshow
(2000). The logistic
regression models were fitted using a stepwise forward inclusion algorithm,
with inclusion and exclusion criteria of P
0.15 and
P
0.2 respectively. If a variable was a significant predictor in
the model, then that variable with all of its sub-categories was used as the
sole predictor of the diagnosis in a new analysis. To obtain a more
parsimonious and interpretable model, sub-categories of the variable within
the single predictor model with similar odds ratios were combined whereas
sub-categories with large confidence intervals were excluded; the overall
logistic regression model was then repeated with the new sub-categories and
all other predictors included in the model. Referents for each variable were
generally chosen based on the sub-category with the largest number of
participants (see Table 5). All
two-way interactions among predictors were evaluated, but none was significant
at P
0.05.
|
View this table: [in a new window] | Table 5 Stepwise logistic regression models to predict psychiatric disorder |
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] | Table 1 Response and cooperation rates |
|
View this table: [in a new window] | Table 2 Demographic characteristics of respondents and non-respondents |
Sample characteristics
Relative to the other branches of the military (Army, Navy, Marines and Air
Force), the sample contained a relatively small number of Coast Guard veterans
(11 nondeployed; 4 deployed), who were excluded from all analyses.
Furthermore, one member of the Gulf War-deployed group had missing data and
was excluded from further analyses (Gulf War group, n=967; era group,
n=784). Relative to the era veterans, a significantly greater
proportion of Gulf War veterans were male, high-school educated, single during
the war, and of African American or other ethnic background
(Table 3). The two groups were
of comparable age. A significantly greater proportion of Gulf veterans were on
active duty prior to the conflict, enlisted and in the Army or Marines,
whereas a greater proportion of era veterans were in the National Guard or
reserves prior to the conflict, officers and in the Air Force. However,
comparison of the demographic profiles of the samples for Gulf War and era
veterans provided by the Department of Defense revealed differences between
the two groups similar to those reflected in our sample of respondents. That
is, Gulf War veterans were somewhat younger and had a greater proportion of
African Americans than the era group. The Gulf War group also had a greater
proportion of men on active duty, in the Army, Navy or Marines, and of
enlisted rank, than the era group (Table
3).
Twelve-month prevalence of psychiatric disorders
Overall, the Gulf War veterans met criteria for one or more psychiatric
disorders more often than the era group
(Table 4). Although little
difference was seen in rates of alcohol dependence, specific phobia, mania and
somatisation, prevalence rates for the remaining anxiety disorders, depression
and drug dependence were two to three times higher for the Gulf War group
relative to the era group. Within the former group, women had higher rates of
every disorder except alcohol and drug dependence. Within the era group, women
had higher rates of every disorder except alcohol dependence. For all
psychiatric disorders, women in the era group had higher rates than male Gulf
War veterans.
|
View this table: [in a new window] | Table 4 Twelve-month prevalence of psychiatric diagnosis for Gulf War veterans v. era veterans, males v. females |
For depression, being deployed to the Gulf, female, high-school educated and enlisted were each significant independent predictors in the logistic regression model (see Table 5). Predictors for anxiety disorders included Gulf deployment, female gender, being divorced at the time of the Gulf War, enlisted relative to non-commissioned officer (NCO) or officer rank, and being in the Army relative to the other services. For alcohol or drug dependence, being male, enlisted, divorced, single or living with someone and deployment other than to the Persian Gulf were significant independent risk factors. No two-way interaction was a significant predictor for any of the psychiatric disorders.
|
|
|---|
For a subset of veterans deployed to sites in addition to the Gulf, these other deployments were associated with an increased risk of alcohol/drug dependence but not of depression or anxiety disorders. Experiencing multiple deployments and being single or divorced may increase the risk of alcohol/drug dependence because of isolation and lack of support, both of which have been associated with increased risk of substance misuse (Grant et al, 2001; Schuckit & Smith, 2001). Other deployments included locations such as Vietnam, for which significantly elevated rates of alcohol misuse or dependence (13.7%) have been reported (CDC Vietnam Experience Study, 1988). However, the number of veterans (n=204) with other deployments is substantially smaller than the number of veterans deployed to the Gulf, making these results less reliable.
Rank and psychiatric disorder
Enlisted status relative to NCO and officer rank was associated with
increased risk of multiple psychiatric disorders including anxiety, depression
and drug/alcohol dependence. Other investigators of Gulf War veterans have
also reported that lower rank is associated with poorer psychological and
physical health (Ismail et al,
2000) and increased risk of multisymptom illness
(Fukuda et al, 1998;
Gray et al, 1998). In
our study, being in the Army increased the risk of an anxiety disorder,
whereas being in the Air Force, Marines or Navy was protective. These findings
suggest that those with the least control by virtue of lower rank are more
likely to be adversely affected by their war experience years after the war
has ended, although causality cannot be inferred from the present study
design. Furthermore, lower rank may be a surrogate for lower socio-economic
status: this is known to contribute to psychiatric disorders and the stresses
that accompany lower status may have contributed to the onset of psychiatric
conditions after the war and/or made it difficult to receive adequate care for
psychiatric conditions that began during the war.
Demographic predictors of psychiatric disorder
Non-military factors, including education, marital status during the war
and gender were also predictive of current psychiatric disorders. Similar to
previous findings from community samples
(Neeleman et al,
2001), veterans with the lowest level of education were at
increased risk of depression relative to their better-educated peers, and
veterans who were divorced at the time of their service in the Gulf were at
increased risk of anxiety disorder and drug/alcohol dependence relative to
those who were married. Divorce has been associated with increased symptoms of
anxiety and depression among individuals both as they go through divorce
(Hackney & Ribordy, 1980)
and also years after the divorce (Richards
et al, 1997). Predictors of dependence disorders included
being male and divorced or single/living with a partner, findings consistent
with community studies that show higher rates of alcohol/drug dependence among
males (Kessler et al,
1994; Grant et al,
2001) and among those who are divorced or never married
(Richards et al,
1997; Grant et al,
2001). These factors suggest that those with less education or who
have other stressors such as divorce show increased risk of psychiatric
disorder beyond the risks associated with military service. Similar to
nonmilitary samples, women were consistently at greater risk for anxiety and
depression but at less risk than men for drug/alcohol dependence
(Kessler et al,
1994). Unwin et al
(2002) did not find gender
differences among UK service personnel deployed to the Persian Gulf conflict
and to Bosnia. However, they evaluated psychological symptoms rather than
psychiatric diagnoses.
Comparison with the National Comorbidity Survey
Although veterans in our study were most probably healthier than the
representative sample of the US population participating in the National
Comorbidity Survey (Kessler et
al, 1994), the 12-month prevalence of psychiatric disorders
for males in the Survey provides a rough comparison for males in our study
(see Table 4). Rates of major
depression, generalised anxiety and simple phobia were approximately doubled
for deployed male veterans relative to the male Survey sample, which in turn
were comparable to the prevalence of these disorders for non-deployed
veterans. Prevalence rates of agoraphobia without panic, panic disorder,
social phobia, mania and drug and alcohol dependence were either comparable or
lower among deployed male veterans relative to US males. With the exception of
generalised anxiety, our results suggest that non-deployed women were at no
greater risk of any disorder relative to community rates reported by Kessler
et al (1994),
although the number of women in our study limits the reliability of our
findings.
Rates of PTSD in the Gulf Wardeployed troops were below those reported by the National Comorbidity Survey, but the latter evaluated lifetime rather than 12-month prevalence. Similarly, McCauley et al (2002) and Wolfe et al (1999) also reported higher rates of PTSD than in our study, although the rates reported by McCauley et al (2002) were based on participants report of a physician diagnosis over the 9 years since the Gulf War, whereas the Wolfe et al (1999) rates were based on a relatively smaller subsample of Gulf War veterans who were high and low symptom reporters and oversampled for women. The current rates for PTSD, however, were comparable with the 3% reported by Ismail et al (2002) for disabled UK Gulf War veterans, disabled Bosnia veterans and era veterans based on assessment of symptoms during the past 4 weeks. Thus, the 12-month prevalence rates of PTSD are comparable for veterans who were deployed and veterans who were disabled, and may reflect the fact that Gulf War veterans combat exposure was relatively less than in previous wars. Prevalence of somatisation was low among Gulf War veterans and was not diagnosed for any era veterans, a finding also consistent with that of Ismail et al (2002), who reported a low prevalence of somatisation disorder among disabled Gulf veterans with no case of somatisation among non-disabled Gulf veterans, disabled Bosnia veterans or era veterans. Ismail et al (2002) reported an increased prevalence of undifferentiated somatoform disorders among disabled Gulf War veterans relative to their comparison groups. This finding appears consistent with increased prevalence of unexplained symptoms among disabled Gulf War veterans, since these symptoms often overlap those defining undifferentiated somatoform disorders.
Implications of the study
This study is the largest random sample of US Gulf War-deployed and era
veterans in which a standardised and validated method was used to evaluate all
Axis I psychiatric disorders. Although the sample size was relatively large,
the overall response rate was suboptimal and may attenuate the
generalisability of this study. Respondents differed from non-respondents,
with the most notable differences being the greater proportions of White and
NCO/officer rank individuals volunteering for the study. However, such
differences are a typical bias in epidemiological surveys, for which White
individuals and those with more education are more likely to volunteer.
Furthermore, demographic factors were controlled for in the logistic
regression models used to predict psychiatric disorders. The psychiatric
diagnoses remain provisional, since interviews were conducted by lay
interviewers rather than trained clinicians. However, because the CIDI is
designed for use by unqualified interviewers, reliance on clinical judgement
is minimised.
The studys results reflect the 12-month prevalence of psychiatric disorders and do not address the prevalence of psychiatric morbidity for the entire period from the end of the conflict up to 10 years after the war. Nevertheless, when other known risk factors for psychiatric illness such as gender, divorce and educational attainment were controlled for, having been deployed remained a significant, independent risk factor for diagnoses of anxiety and/or depression, whereas being of lower rank (i.e. enlisted) increased risks for all psychiatric disorders. These findings suggest that in addition to the usual demographic risk factors for psychiatric illness, veterans have the burden of increased risk as a result of their deployment, particularly if they were of lower rank. The effects of a relatively brief war with limited physical trauma have a lasting impact on veterans that could be attenuated by prevention programmes to reduce the impact of war on veterans mental health.
|
|
|---|
LIMITATIONS
|
|
|---|
Research, in part, was supported by grants from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC; U50/CCU214463) and the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Center (P30ESO5022). The CDC awarded the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey and Robert Wood Johnson Medical School a cooperative agreement to conduct this project. Consequently, scientists with the CDC were involved in the study design, collection, analysis and interpretation of the data, and also reviewed the manuscript before it was submitted for publication.
|
|
|---|
Related articles in BJP:
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. Wilson, M. Jones, N. T. Fear, L. Hull, M. Hotopf, S. Wessely, and R. J. Rona Is Previous Psychological Health Associated With the Likelihood of Iraq War Deployment? An Investigation of the "Healthy Warrior Effect" Am. J. Epidemiol., June 1, 2009; 169(11): 1362 - 1369. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
I. G. Jacobson, T. C. Smith, B. Smith, P. K. Keel, P. J. Amoroso, T. S. Wells, G. P. Bathalon, E. J. Boyko, M. A. K. Ryan, and for the Millennium Cohort Study Team Disordered Eating and Weight Changes After Deployment: Longitudinal Assessment of a Large US Military Cohort Am. J. Epidemiol., February 15, 2009; 169(4): 415 - 427. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. W Hoge, J. C Clark, and C. A Castro Commentary: Women in combat and the risk of post-traumatic stress disorder and depression Int. J. Epidemiol., April 1, 2007; 36(2): 327 - 329. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||