© 2006 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Highlights of this issue
DEPRESSION – IMPACT OF INTERVENTIONS IN DIFFERENT SETTINGS
Two systematic reviews of treatment interventions for depression are presented in the Journal this month. Gilbody et al (pp. 297–308) have reviewed economic studies of interventions to improve management of depression in primary care. Enhanced care models, such as case management and collaborative care, were found to have clinical benefits but incurred greater costs. Educational strategies did not lead to improved outcomes despite their increased associated costs. Ruhé et al (pp. 309–316) reviewed the evidence for selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor dose escalation, a practice widely employed for those with major depression demonstrating an insufficient response to initial treatment. No evidence could be found to support dose escalation within the first 4 weeks of treatment and only limited evidence was found to support escalation in partial responders after 8 weeks.
Depression is known to have a negative impact on risks among those with coronary heart disease. Dickens et al (pp. 367–372) have found that levels of depression and anxiety after first myocardial infarction predict subsequent impairment in the physical aspects of quality of life. This relationship with physical quality of life 12 months post-infarct did not hold for depression and anxiety present prior to the myocardial infarction event.
SYMPTOM DIMENSIONS AND SOCIAL COGNITION IN PSYCHOSIS
Dikeos et al (pp. 346–353) compared symptom dimensions between different diagnostic groups by employing factor analysis in a sample of patients with a range of psychotic disorders. They identified five factors (mania, reality distortion, depression, disorganisation, negative symptoms). The authors found that diagnosis alone explained much of the variability in clinical characteristics but that dimensions added to the explanation. Deficits in social knowledge and social perception, two components of social cognition, were found by Addington et al (pp. 373–378) to be present to the same degree in both first-episode psychosis and chronic schizophrenia samples, with the identified deficits remaining stable over time in both groups. Evidence for a mediating effect of social cognition on the relationship between cognition and social functioning was also found.
CLINICAL USE OF OUTCOME MEASURES AND CONSIDERATION OF PERCEIVED NEEDS
Clinicians do not routinely use standardised outcome measures in mental health services, perhaps because they remain unconvinced of their likely effectiveness. Slade et al (pp. 330–336) conducted an exploratory randomised controlled trial to test an intervention involving regular completion of questionnaires by patients and staff followed by provision of feedback. The intervention did not improve levels of patient-rated unmet need or quality of life but did reduce psychiatric bed-days and thus service costs. Elbogen et al (pp. 354–360) report that community violence among those included in an out-patient sample drawn from five US states was inversely related to patient perception of treatment need. The authors contend that consideration of patients’ perceptions of needs for treatment may aid risk assessment in clinical settings.
ROLE OF BDNF GENE IN BIPOLAR DISORDER
Findings from genetic studies of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in mood disorders have been mixed. Müller et al (pp. 317–323) examined the role of BDNF gene polymorphisms (four single-nucleotide polymorphisms and the Val66Met and GT(n) repeat polymorphisms) across the illness categories of bipolar I, bipolar II and rapid-cycling disorder. They found evidence that rapid cycling is an important feature in the phenotype associated with the BDNF gene although the effect size of the gene was small.
ADVERSE OUTCOMES IN FAMILY MEMBERS
Children and siblings of people with schizophrenia were found by Glatt et al (pp. 337–345) to have deficits compared with controls in several areas of psychopathology, personality and social development. Greater deficits in reward dependence, problems with peers and with members of the opposite gender were associated with increased genetic loading. In a longitudinal study by Stein et al (pp. 324–329), the 10-year-old children of mothers with eating disorders were found to be more likely to exhibit dietary restraint and to hold overvalued ideas about weight/shape compared with controls. They did not have elevated levels of general psychopathology and thus the authors conclude that maternal eating disorder may have a specific effect on the eating habits and attitudes of their offspring.
IMPACT OF AUTISM ON TEENAGERS WITH LEARNING DISABILITY
Bradley & Bolton (pp. 361–366) found that teenagers with learning disability and autism experienced more episodes of psychiatric illness than those without autism. Major depression was the most common illness in both groups, whereas bipolar affective disorder occurred only in the autism group. The prescription of antipsychotic medication was associated with the presence of episodic disorders and prescription of stimulant medication with the presence of autism.
Related articles in BJP:
- Costs and consequences of enhanced primary care for depression: Systematic review of randomised economic evaluations
- SIMON GILBODY, PETER BOWER, and PAULA WHITTY
BJP 2006 189: 297-308.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Dose escalation for insufficient response to standard-dose selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors in major depressive disorder: Systematic review
- HENRICUS G. RUHÉ, JOCHANAN HUYSER, JAN A. SWINKELS, and AART H. SCHENE
BJP 2006 189: 309-316.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) gene and rapid-cycling bipolar disorder: Family-based association study
- DANIEL J. MÜLLER, VINCENZO DE LUCA, TRICIA SICARD, NICOLE KING, JOHN STRAUSS, and JAMES L. KENNEDY
BJP 2006 189: 317-323.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Eating habits and attitudes among 10-year-old children of mothers with eating disorders: Longitudinal study
- ALAN STEIN, HELEN WOOLLEY, SANDRA COOPER, JONATHAN WINTERBOTTOM, CHRISTOPHER G. FAIRBURN, and MARIO CORTINA-BORJA
BJP 2006 189: 324-329.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Use of standardised outcome measures in adult mental health services: Randomised controlled trial
- MIKE SLADE, PAUL McCRONE, ELIZABETH KUIPERS, MORVEN LEESE, SHARON CAHILL, ALBERTO PARABIAGHI, STEFAN PRIEBE, and GRAHAM THORNICROFT
BJP 2006 189: 330-336.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Psychopathology, personality traits and social development of young first-degree relatives of patients with schizophrenia
- STEPHEN J. GLATT, WILLIAM S. STONE, STEPHEN V. FARAONE, LARRY J. SEIDMAN, and MING T. TSUANG
BJP 2006 189: 337-345.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Distribution of symptom dimensions across Kraepelinian divisions
- DIMITRIS G. DIKEOS, HARVEY WICKHAM, COLM McDONALD, MURIEL WALSHE, THORDUR SIGMUNDSSON, ELVIRA BRAMON, ANTON GRECH, TIMOTHEA TOULOPOULOU, ROBIN MURRAY, and PAK C. SHAM
BJP 2006 189: 346-353.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Treatment engagement and violence risk in mental disorders
- ERIC B. ELBOGEN, RICHARD A. VAN DORN, JEFFREY W. SWANSON, MARVIN S. SWARTZ, and JOHN MONAHAN
BJP 2006 189: 354-360.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Episodic psychiatric disorders in teenagers with learning disabilities with and without autism
- ELSPETH BRADLEY and PATRICK BOLTON
BJP 2006 189: 361-366.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Contribution of depression and anxiety to impaired health-related quality of life following first myocardial infarction
- C. M. DICKENS, L. McGOWAN, C. PERCIVAL, B. TOMENSON, L. COTTER, A. HEAGERTY, and F. H. CREED
BJP 2006 189: 367-372.[Abstract] [Full Text] - Influence of social perception and social knowledge on cognitive and social functioning in early psychosis
- JEAN ADDINGTON, HUMA SAEEDI, and DONALD ADDINGTON
BJP 2006 189: 373-378.[Abstract] [Full Text]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||