Department of Psychology, Queens College, City University of New York
Department of Psychiatry, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York
Department of Psychology, Queens College, City University of New York
Department of Psychology, Queens College, City University of New York and Department of Psychiatry, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York
Correspondence: Dr Janine D. Flory, Department of Psychology, Queens College, City University of New York (CUNY), 65-30 Kissena Boulevard, SB318 Flushing, NY 11367, USA. Email: janine.flory{at}qc.cuny.edu
Funding detailed in Acknowledgements.
|
|
|---|
Aims The current study examined the prospective relationship between serotonergic function measured in childhood and the later emergence of antisocial personality disorder.
Method Hormonal response to fenfluramine, an index of serotonergic function, was assessed in 58 children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder between 1990 and 1997 when they were aged 7-11 years. Approximately 9 years later these individuals were evaluated for antisocial personality disorder.
Results Lower serotonergic responsivity assessed in childhood predicted the development of antisocial personality disorder (t (56)=2.25, P=0.028).
Conclusions These results provide a critical link between the child and adult literature on the covariation of impulsive aggression and serotonergic function and suggest a potential explanation for inconsistencies in the childhood literature.
|
|
|---|
In contrast to this large and consistent body of work, the evidence linking dysregulated serotonergic function and aggression among children is equivocal (Kruesi et al, 1990; Stoff et al, 1992; Castellanos et al, 1994; Halperin et al, 1994, 1997; Pine et al, 1997). One reason might be the exclusive focus on cross-sectional studies of childhood and early adolescence when aggression is temporally unstable (Moffitt, 1993); longitudinal research that examines the neurobiological correlates of temporally persistent aggression might yield more consistent findings. In support of this view, one prospective study links lower 5-hydroxyindole acetic acid (5-HIAA) levels in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of boys with disruptive behaviour disorders to aggression scores/arrests measured 2 years later (Kruesi et al, 1992). The current study capitalised on the unique opportunity to observe the prospective relationship between serotonergic function assessed in childhood and the emergence of antisocial personality disorder in late adolescence/young adulthood. We predicted that a lower prolactin response to fenfluramine in childhood would be associated with the development of antisocial personality disorder assessed 9 years later.
|
|
|---|
The current report is based on the total number of participants with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) who had undergone the childhood evaluation including a fenfluramine challenge and who were later interviewed for identification of Axis II psychopathology between August 2001 and February 2005. The sample included 52 males and 6 females and represents 53% of the total number of children who were administered the fenfluramine challenge and were eligible for follow-up in February 2005 (n=110). Participation in the follow-up evaluation was not associated with gender, socio-economic status, age at initial evaluation, IQ, or parent and teacher ratings of psychopathology (P<0.18). At baseline, all 58 children (mean age 9.24, s.d.=1.19 years) met diagnostic criteria for ADHD and 47 were diagnosed with oppositional-defiant disorder; 21 met criteria for conduct disorder.
Fenfluramine challenge
Following the clinical evaluation and prior to the day of the challenge
protocol, participants followed a low monoamine diet for 3 days and reported
to the laboratory at 08.00 h after fasting overnight. An indwelling catheter
was inserted into a forearm vein. Following an adaptation period, baseline
blood samples were drawn at 09.45 h and 09.55 h. At 10.00 h, a 1 mg/kg dose of
d,l-fenfluramine hydrochloride was administered orally. Blood samples were
drawn 60, 120, 180, 240 and 300 min later for determination of plasma
prolactin, fenfluramine and norfenfluramine concentrations. All samples were
placed on ice prior to centrifugation (within 2 h). After separation, samples
were frozen at 80° C until analysis. The lower limit of detection
for the prolactin assay is <1.0 ng/ml. Intra- and interassay variability
are less than 6.7% and 8.4% respectively. Blood samples for determination of
plasma fenfluramine and norfenfluramine were drawn hourly. After separation,
these samples were frozen at 20° C prior to assay by gas
chromatography with electrical detection. The lower limit of sensitivity for
these assays is 2 ng/ml for fenfluramine and 3 ng/ml for norfenfluramine.
Intra- and interassay variability for the two assays are less than 7%.
Participants remained awake and fasting during the entire procedure, reclining
in a bed and watching videotapes. All fenfluramine studies were completed
prior to September 1997.
Follow-up evaluation
Participants who were evaluated for ADHD in childhood were contacted to
participate in a study of the longitudinal course of ADHD. The mean (s.d.) age
at follow-up was 18.44 (1.23) years; follow-up took place on average 9.4 years
later (s.d.=1.9 years). Seventeen participants identified themselves as
African American, 18 as non-Hispanic White, 18 as Black Hispanic and 5 as
mixed race. The participants were generally of lower- to lower-middle
socio-economic status (SES) (mean SES score 44.59, s.d.=15.62;
Nakao & Treas, 1994). At
follow-up, all participants and a parent or adult relative (informant) were
administered the Structured Clinical Interview for DSMIV Axis II
Personality Disorders (SCIDII; First
et al, 1997).
Although diagnoses of personality disorder have not traditionally been assigned to people under 18, there is growing acceptance that personality disorder diagnoses can be made reliably in adolescence (e.g. Bernstein et al, 1993; Johnson et al, 1995) and DSMIVTR (American Psychiatric Association, 2000) allows for this if the symptoms are persistent and present for at least 1 year. In the case of antisocial personality disorder, a prior diagnosis of conduct disorder is also required and, by definition, it is the only personality disorder diagnosis that cannot be made in individuals under 18. In the current study, because the SCIDII interview was used for research purposes it was administered to all participants regardless of age; if they were found to meet criteria for conduct disorder based on the interview, the criteria for antisocial personality disorder were also evaluated. Interviewers were masked to baseline data, including whether children had been given a diagnosis of conduct disorder during the baseline study, and the interviews were conducted independently (i.e. the same interviewer did not interview the participant and informant). Proband and informant interviews were not conducted for all participants; one proband died prior to evaluation and three probands did not identify an informant. If either the participant or the informant endorsed criteria for antisocial personality disorder, the participant was considered to carry the diagnosis. Concordance (Pearson's r) between ratings was 0.62.
Signed informed consent was obtained from participants over 18 years and from parents for participants under 18, in whom assent was obtained. The protocol was approved by the institutional review boards at Queens College, City University of New York and Mount Sinai School of Medicine.
Data reduction and statistical analyses
Baseline prolactin level was calculated as the mean of two blood samples
collected prior to administration of fenfluramine and area under the curve
(AUC PRL[fen]) was calculated using trapezoidal integration
(Pruessner et al,
2003). Both baseline prolactin and AUC PRL[fen] were
log-transformed prior to analyses to normalise the distributions. Owing to the
moderate association between baseline prolactin and AUC (r=0.57), log
AUC PRL[fen] was regressed on log baseline prolactin to obtain a
baseline-independent measure of serotonergic responsivity. This served as the
major outcome measure of serotonergic responsivity. Fenfluramine and
norfenfluramine levels during the challenge were averaged across time but were
unavailable for three participants. These averages were found to be correlated
with log AUC PRL[fen] (r=0.45 and 0.39 respectively); log AUC
PRL[fen] was thus adjusted for covariation with log baseline prolactin
concentration and drug levels using linear regression. The hypothesis that
lower serotonergic responsivity would predict the development of antisocial
personality disorder was evaluated using two-tailed Student's
t-tests.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (9K): [in a new window] [as a PowerPoint slide] |
Fig. 1 Plasma prolactin concentrations following administration of a 1 mg/kg dose
of d,l-fenfluramine hydrochloride. - - - -, Antisocial personality
disorder;
|
Criteria for antisocial personality disorder were evaluated if participants met criteria for conduct disorder on the SCIDII, even if they were under age 18. However, post hoc analyses included only participants who were 18 years or over at the time of the interview assessment (n=33). Despite loss in statistical power, results indicated that lower serotonergic responsivity was associated with the development of antisocial personality disorder, (t (31)=2.32, P=0.03).
Finally, an exploratory forward selection stepwise logistic regression
analysis using maximum likelihood estimates was conducted to examine the
relative influence of childhood conduct disorder, childhood aggression (IOWA
Connors Aggression Scale) and childhood serotonergic function
(baseline-adjusted log AUC PRL[fen]) in predicting a diagnosis of antisocial
personality disorder. Results indicated that a model that included
serotonergic functioning and childhood aggression was significant
(
2(2)=13.22, P=0.001, 2LL=53.79). Serotonergic
functioning entered the model first (B=3.05, 95% CI
5.43 to 0.68), z=6.4, P=0.012), followed by
childhood aggression (B=0.21 (95% CI 0.040.38);
z=6.2, P=0.013). Odds ratios are not reported because
serotonergic functioning is represented by a log transformation of AUC, which
is not a meaningful unit of measurement.
|
|
|---|
Moreover, these results provide a critical link between the child and adult literature on the covariation of impulsive aggression and serotonergic function because this is the only study that spans the developmental period between childhood and early adulthood.
Other studies
A potential explanation for inconsistencies in the childhood literature is
that aggressive and delinquent behaviour across childhood and adolescence is
temporally unstable and less tightly linked to individual variation in
serotonergic function than in adulthood. Developmental theories of antisocial
personality disorder propose alternative trajectories from childhood to
adulthood, including continuous or life-course-persistent and transitory or
adolescence-limited antisocial behaviour
(DiLalla & Gottesman, 1989;
Moffitt, 1993). These theories
propose that delinquent behaviour in children that persists into adulthood is
a more heritable or biologically mediated form of behaviour that likely
includes aggression and violence. This view is supported by a twin study
showing that age at onset moderates the association between genetic and
environmental influences on antisocial behaviour
(Slutske et al, 1997)
and a meta-analysis of twin studies of aggression
(Miles & Carey, 1997),
which concluded that heritability estimates of aggression increase from
childhood to adulthood, whereas the relative magnitude of environmental
influences decreases. In the current study, we observed that boys who went on
to develop antisocial personality disorder had more relatives with such a
diagnosis, which is consistent with our previous report that aggressive
children with higher familial aggregation of aggressive and antisocial
behaviours show a lower prolactin response to fenfluramine
(Halperin et al,
2003).
In contrast to life-course-persistent antisocial behaviour, many adolescents engage in more `normative' forms of delinquent behaviour, including substance use. Because the base rate of this behaviour is so high, it is correlated with neither childhood nor adult behaviour. Of the 21 children diagnosed with conduct disorder in childhood in the current sample, only about half (n=11) went on to develop antisocial personality disorder, corresponding to the stability data reported by Lahey et al (2005) in a longitudinal study of conduct disorder first assessed in childhood. In addition, seven individuals who met criteria for antisocial personality disorder did not carry a diagnosis of conduct disorder at the time of the childhood evaluation, although six of the seven met criteria for oppositional defiant disorder, another precursor for antisocial personality disorder. In these, features of conduct disorder emerged after the childhood evaluation, and indeed, were apparent at the time of assessment of antisocial personality disorder. It should also be noted that children who did not meet full criteria for conduct disorder during childhood would not necessarily be considered `non-aggressive'. Because all children met criteria for a disruptive behaviour disorder upon study entry, they might have exhibited features of conduct disorder that did not reach the threshold level for diagnosis.
The results from the current study are not informative regarding the origins of the covariation between dysregulated serotonergic activity and antisocial personality disorder. Pedigree studies suggest that indices of serotonin (e.g. whole blood, CSF 5-HIAA levels) are heritable (Higley et al, 1993; Abney et al, 2001), as are measures of aggression and antisocial behaviour (Miles & Carey, 1997; Slutske et al, 1997). Environmental conditions suggestive of social adversity (e.g. peer rearing in non-human primates (Shannon et al, 2005) and poverty and unemployment (Manuck et al, 2005b)) are associated with dysregulated serotonergic function and these social factors may interact with functional variants of serotonin-regulating genes to confer greater risk for antisocial personality disorder (Caspi et al, 2002). Because the current sample included only children with disruptive behaviour disorders, in whom we would expect to see a full complement of genetic and environmental risk predictors for antisocial personality disorder, we cannot disentangle the relative impact of these factors on serotonergic function prior to age 7. Moreover, we do not posit that dysregulated serotonergic function is the sole feature that leads to antisocial personality disorder, but consider it one aspect of a complex interplay between biological and psychosocial variables.
Limitations of the study
Limitations of the current study should be acknowledged. The sample size
was small and prospective replication of the association is warranted.
However, the extended length of follow-up and the fact that the association
between serotonergic functioning and antisocial personality disorder could not
be explained by common risk factors (e.g. gender, IQ, SES) suggests that the
finding is robust. The sample was predominantly male and the findings may not
generalise to girls, but we note that the results were unchanged upon
exclusion of females from the analyses. In addition, although it is of great
interest to identify neurobiological features that are associated with
specific aspects of antisocial personality disorder (e.g.
Yang et al, 2005),
the number of people meeting the criteria for such a diagnosis was considered
too small to conduct these analyses.
Limitations of the method used for measuring central serotonergic function should be acknowledged. Throughout the 1980s and 1990s hormonal responsivity to fenfluramine was a well-established and frequently-used measure for assessing serotonergic function in the hypothalamicpituitary axis and the procedure is considered to reflect `net' serotonergic transmission from the raphe nuclei to the hypothalamus, including both presynaptic and postsynaptic functioning (Coccaro et al, 1989; Yatham & Steiner, 1993), although data suggest that the findings may generalise to the prefrontal cortex (Soloff et al, 2000). This method of assessment has been largely supplanted by neuroimaging which affords greater regional specificity of central serotonergic pathways and receptor activity. In addition, it should be noted that fenfluramine was withdrawn from the US market in 1997 when safety concerns curtailed its continued use in neurobiological research, which prevented us from repeating biological assessment in our young adult sample.
Antisocial personality disorder is a heterogeneous entity that includes overlapping constructs: criminal behaviour, impulsive aggression and a lack of remorse for transgressions. The literature suggests that dysregulated serotonergic function will be associated prospectively with impulsive aggression rather than other aspects of antisocial personality disorder, but this hypothesis awaits verification.
The age range of the current sample spans the time of the developmental transition from adolescence into young adulthood and it will be critical to follow these individuals over the next 510 years to determine whether their current levels of behaviour persist. The longitudinal nature of this study will enable us to examine specific childhood neurobiological and psychosocial predictors of the persistence of aggression and related forms of antisocial behaviour.
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Related articles in BJP:
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Tyrer The British Journal of Psychiatry, January 1, 2008; 192(1): 82 - 82. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||