© 2007 The Royal College of Psychiatrists
Correspondence |
Hot weather and suicide: a real risk or statistical illusion?
Department of Psychiatry, Peasley Cross Hospital, St Helens WA9 3DA, UK. Email: esalib{at}hotmail.com
Department of Statistics, Institute of Child Health, UCL, London, UK
Department of Psychiatry, Peasley Cross Hospital, St Helens, UK
EDITED BY KIRIAKOS XENITIDIS and COLIN CAMPBELL
Page et al (2007) reported an association between increased risk of suicide and hot weather. We believe it is important that this finding is compared with similar associations reported in other countries and under similar conditions, particularly for countries with hotter climates but also for those moving through a period of climatic change.
We are a little disappointed that despite the authors' excellent statistical analyses and effective display of results, they determined the shape of their natural cubic splines `visually' instead of using some model selection criterion, for example likelihood ratio tests, Akaike's information criterion (AIC), etc. Page et al also stated that Yip et al (2000) `failed to show any significant seasonality with recent UK data'. This may not be entirely accurate as we believe that Yip et al (2000) showed a decreasing seasonal pattern but not that the pattern had vanished.
The `unexpected' reduction in suicide during the heatwave of 2003 reported by Page et al is difficult to explain on the basis of temperature alone, particularly as there was a 13.5-33% increase in general mortality during the 2003 heatwave (Kovats et al, 2006). It is clear that the association of increased mortality with high temperature is not specific to suicide. Hajat et al (2002) reported an almost identical increase in all-cause mortality of 3.34% (95% CI 2.47-4.23) for every 1°C increase in mean temperature above 18°C compared with the 3.8% increase in suicide reported by Page et al. This raises the possibility of an unaccounted confounder linking suicide, total mortality and daily mean temperature above 18°C. Such factors include climatic and non-climatic factors, whether acting independently or as interaction terms, for example number of sunshine hours (Salib & Gray, 1997), relative humidity, rainfall, unusual weather conditions, stress resulting in changes in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis or even changes in the solar wind as measured by satellites (Richardson et al, 1994). Chronomics of suicides (Halberg et al, 2005) which do not rely on calendar year but on periodicity of solar wind (Richardson et al, 1994) may provide a plausible and alternative explanation to the findings of Page et al.
Perhaps the only conclusion that can be drawn from reading Page et al's paper is that high temperature may be associated with increased all-cause mortality. Given the very similar rate of increase in all-cause mortality and in suicide, the mechanism by which high temperature affects the rate of suicide should not be expected to differ from that operating for other causes of death.
Although high daily mean temperature may increase suicide risk, this is not an independent risk factor and may not have the implications for public health policy in relation to global warming that Page et al indicated.
REFERENCES
- Hajat, S., Kovats, R. S., Atkinson, R. W., et al
(2002) Impact of hot temperatures on death in London: a time
series approach. Journal of Epidemiology and Community
Health, 56, 367
-372.
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Halberg, F., Cornélissen, G., Panksepp, J., et al (2005) Chronomics of autism and suicide. Biomedicine and Pharmacotherapy, 59 (suppl. 1), S100 -S108.[CrossRef]
- Kovats, R. S., Johnson, H. & Griffith, C. (2006) Mortality in southern England during 2003 heat wave by place of death. Health Statistics Quarterly, 29, 6-8.[Medline]
- Page, L. A., Hajat, S. & Kovats, R. S.
(2007) Relationship between daily suicide counts and
temperature in England and Wales. British Journal of
Psychiatry, 191, 106
-112.
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Richardson, J. D., Paularena, K. I., Belcher, J., et al (1994) Solar wind oscillation with 1.3 pear period. Geographical Research Letters, 21, 1559 -1560.
- Salib, E. & Gray, N. (1997) Weather
conditions and fatal self-harm in North Cheshire 1989-1993. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 171, 473
-477.
[Abstract/Free Full Text] - Yip, P. S. F., Chao, A. & Chiu, C. W. F.
(2000) Seasonal variation in suicides: diminished or
vanished. Experience from England and Wales, 1982-1996. British
Journal of Psychiatry, 177, 366
-369.
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||