Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-tj2md Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T12:49:35.369Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Home-Based Versus Hospital-Based Care for People with Serious Mental Illness

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  02 January 2018

I. M. Marks ,
J. Connolly ,
M. Muijen ,
B. Audini ,
G. McNamee  and
R. E. Lawrence
I. M. Marks*
Affiliation:
Institute of Psychiatry and Bethlem-Maudsley Hospital
J. Connolly
Affiliation:
Bethlem-Maudsley Hospital
M. Muijen
Affiliation:
Sainsbury Centre for Mental Health, London SE1
B. Audini
Affiliation:
Royal College of Psychiatrists Research Unit
G. McNamee
Affiliation:
West Lambeth Community Care Trust, London SW9
R. E. Lawrence
Affiliation:
West Lambeth Community Care Trust, London SW9
*
Professor I. M. Marks, Institute of Psychiatry, De Crespigny Park, Denmark Hill, London SE5 8AF
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Background.

A controlled study tested whether the superior outcome of community care for serious mental illness (SMI) in Madison and in Sydney would also be found in inner London.

Method.

Patients from an inner London catchment area who faced emergency admission for SMI (many were violent or suicidal) were randomised to 20 months or more of either home-based care (Daily Living Programme, DLP; n = 92), or standard in-patient and later out-patient care (controls, n = 97). Most DLP patients had brief in-patient stays at some time. Measures included number and duration of in-patient admissions, independent ratings of clinical and social function, and patients' and relatives' satisfaction.

Results.

Outcome was superior with home-based care. Until month 20, DLP care improved symptoms and social adjustment slightly more, and enhanced patients' and relatives' satisfaction. From 3 to 18 months DLP care greatly reduced the number of in-patient bed days as long as the DLP team was responsible for any in-patient phase its patients had. Cost was less. DLP care did not reduce the number of admissions, nor of deaths from self-harm (3 DLP, 2 control). One DLP patient killed a child. Even at 20 months many DLP and control patients still had severe symptoms, poor social adjustment, no job, and need for assertive follow-up and heavy staff input. (Beyond 20 months most gains were lost apart from satisfaction.)

Conclusions.

It is unclear how much the gain until 20 months from home-based care was due to its site of care, its being problem-centred, its teaching of daily living skills, its assertive follow-up, the home care team's keeping responsibility for any in-patient phase, its coordination of total care (case management), or to other care components. Home-based care is hard to organise and vulnerable to many factors, and needs careful training and clinical audit if gains are to be sustained.

Type
Papers
Information
The British Journal of Psychiatry , Volume 165 , Issue 2 , August 1994 , pp. 179 - 194
Copyright
Copyright © Royal College of Psychiatrists, 1994 

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Attkison, C. C. & Zwick, R. (1985) The Client Satisfaction Questionnaire: Psychometric properties and correlation with service utilization and psychotherapy outcome. Evaluation and Program Planning, 5, 233–237.Google Scholar
Bebbington, P. & Feeney, S. (1991) The use of inpatient beds in the joint hospital: Report of an audit of bed usage to the Bethlem-Maudsley Hospital.Google Scholar
Burns, T., Beadsmoore, A., Bhat, A. V., et al, (1993) A controlled trial of home-based acute psychiatric services. British Journal of Psychiatry, 163, 49–61.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Coates, D. B., Kendall, L. M., MacCurdy, E. A. & Goodacre, R. H. (1976) Evaluating hospital and home treatment for psychiatric patients. Canada's Mental Health, 24, 28–32.Google Scholar
Cohen, L. J., Test, M. A. & Brown, R. L. (1990) Suicide and schizophrenia: data from a prospective community treatment study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 147, 602–607.Google ScholarPubMed
Cooper, J. E., Kendell, R. E., Gurland, B. J., et al (1972) Psychiatric Diagnosis in New York and London. Maudsley Monograph No. 20. London: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Creed, F., Black, D., Anthony, P., et al (1990) Randomised controlled trial of day patient versus inpatient psychiatric treatment. British Medical Journal, 300, 1033–1037.Google Scholar
Dean, C. & Gadd, E. M. (1990) Home treatment for acute psychiatric illness. British Medical Journal, 301, 1021–1023.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dick, P., Cameron, L., Cohen, D., et al (1985) Day and full time psychiatric treatment – a controlled comparison. British Journal of Psychiatry, 147, 246–249.Google Scholar
Endicott, J., Spitzer, R. L., Fleiss, J. L. & Cohen, J. (1976) The Global Assessment Scale. A procedure for measuring overall severity of psychiatric disturbance. Archives of General Psychiatry, 33, 766–771.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fenton, F. R., Tessier, L. & Struening, L. L. (1979) A comparative trial of home and hospital psychiatric care. One-year follow-up. Archives of General Psychiatry, 36, 1073–1079.Google Scholar
Fenton, F. R., Tessier, L. & Struening, L. L. et al (1982a) Home and Hospital Psychiatric Treatment. London: Croom Helm.Google ScholarPubMed
Fenton, F. R., Tessier, L., Contandriopoulos, A. P., et al (1982b) A comparative trial of home and hospital psychiatric treatment: financial costs. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 27, 177–187.Google Scholar
Grad, J. & Sainsbury, P. (1968) The effects that patients have on their families in a community care and a control psychiatric service – a two year follow-up. British Journal of Psychiatry, 114, 265–278.Google Scholar
Hedlund, J. L. & Vieweg, B. W. (1980) The brief psychiatric rating scale: a comprehensive review. Journal of Operational Psychiatry, 11, 48–63.Google Scholar
Herz, M. I., Endicott, J. & Spitzer, R. L. (1975) Brief hospitalization: a prospective controlled study. VI. Two year follow-up results for schizophrenics. Archives of General Psychiatry, 34, 305–311.Google Scholar
Hirsch, S. R. (1988) Psychiatric Beds and Resources: Factors Influencing Bed Use and Service Planning. London: Gaskell.Google Scholar
Hoult, J. (1990) Dissemination in New South Wales of the Madison model. In Mental Health Care Delivery: Innovations, Impediments and Implementation (eds Marks, I. M. & Scott, R.), ch. 4, pp. 41–57. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Tessier, L., Reynolds, I., Charbonneau-Powis, M., et al (1983) Psychiatric hospital versus community treatment: a randomised trial. Australia and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 17, 160–167 and report to Department of Health, New South Wales.Google Scholar
Tessier, L., Rosen, A. & Reynolds, I. (1984) Community orientated treatment compared to psychiatric hospital orientated treatment. Social Scientific Medicine, 18, 1005–1010.Google Scholar
Johnstone, E., Owens, D., Gold, A., et al (1981) Institutionalisation and the defects of schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry, 139, 195–203.Google Scholar
Kennedy, P. & Hird, F. (1980) Description and evaluation of a short-stay admission ward. British Journal of Psychiatry, 136, 205–216.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kiesler, C. A. (1982) Mental health policy as a field of inquiry for psychology. American Psychologist, 35, 1066–1080.Google Scholar
Knapp, M., Cambridge, P., Thomason, C., et al (1992) Care in the Community: Challenge and Demonstration. Canterbury: University of Kent PSSRU.Google Scholar
Knights, A., Hirsch, S. R. & Platt, S. D. (1980) Clinical change as a function of brief admission to hospital in a controlled study using the PSE. British Journal of Psychiatry, 137, 170–180.Google Scholar
Langsley, D. G., Machotka, P. & Flomenhaft, K. (1971) Avoiding mental hospital admission, a follow-up study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 1391–1394.Google Scholar
Larsen, D. H., Attkison, C. C., Hargreaves, W. A. & Nguyen, T. D. (1979) Assessment of client/patient satisfaction: development of a general scale. Evaluation and Program Planning, 2, 197–207.Google Scholar
Lawrence, R. E. (1991) The impact of community care on the course of schizophrenia in Kidderminster. In The Closure of Mental Hospitals (eds Hale, P. & Brockington, I.), pp. 76–81. London: Gaskell.Google Scholar
Lawrence, R. E., Cumella, S. & Robertson, J. A. (1988) Patterns of care in a district general psychiatric unit. British Journal of Psychiatry, 152, 188–195.Google Scholar
Lawrence, R. E., Copas, J. B. & Cooper, P. J. (1991) Community care: Does it reduce the need for psychiatric beds? British Journal of Psychiatry, 159, 334–340.Google Scholar
Leff, J. (1991) Evaluation of the closure of a mental hospital. In The Closure of Mental Hospitals (eds Hall, P. & Brockington, I. F.), ch. 4, pp.25–32. London: Gaskell.Google Scholar
Leff, J. P. & Wing, J. (1971) Trial of maintenance therapy in schizophrenia. British Medical Journal, 2, 599–604.Google Scholar
Lemmens, F. & Donker, M. (1990) Kwaliteitsbeoordeling door clienten: Utrecht: Nederlands Centrum Geestelijke Volksgezondheid.Google Scholar
Luborsky, L. (1962) Clinicians' judgment of mental health. Archives of General Psychiatry, 7, 407–417.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Lukoff, D., Liberman, R. P. & Nuechterlein, K. H. (1986) Symptom monitoring in the rehabilitation of schizophrenic patients. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 12, 578–602.Google Scholar
Marks, I. M. (1992) Innovations in mental health care delivery. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 589–597.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Marks, I. M. (1994) Synopsis of the Daily Living Program for the seriously mentally ill: A controlled comparison of home- vs hospital-based care. In Community Treatments for Acute Psychiatric Illness (eds Creed, F. & Tyrer, P.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Marks, I. M. & Scott, R., (eds) (1990) Mental Health Care Delivery: Innovations, Impediments and Implementation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Melzer, D., Hale, A. S., Malik, S. H., et al (1991) Community care for patients with schizophrenia one year after hospital discharge. British Medical Journal, 303, 1023–1026.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Merson, S., Tyrer, P., Onyett, S., et al (1992) Early intervention in psychiatric emergencies: A controlled clinical trial. Lancet, 339, 1311–1314.Google Scholar
Morgan, H. G. (1992) Suicide prevention hazards on the fast lane to community care. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 149–153.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Muijen, M. (1991) A controlled community care study in serious mental illness. (PhD dissertation, University of London)Google Scholar
Muijen, M. & McNamee, G. (1989) A visitor's view of Madison's PACT program and Dane County Mental Health Center. Psychiatric Bulletin, 13, 352–355.Google Scholar
Muijen, M., Marks, I. M., Connolly, J. & Audini, B. (1992a) Home-based care vs standard hospital-based care for the severely mentally ill: short-term outcome. British Medical Journal, 304, 749–754.Google Scholar
Muijen, M., Marks, I. M., Connolly, J. & Audini, B. et al (1992b) The Daily Living Program: Preliminary comparison of community vs hospital-based treatment for the seriously mentally ill facing emergency admission. British Journal of Psychiatry, 160, 379–384.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Overall, J. E. & Gorham, D. R. (1962) Impact of treatment intervention on the relationship between dimensions of clinical psychopathology, social dysfunction and burden on the family of psychiatric patients. British Journal of Psychiatry, 12, 651–658.Google Scholar
Pai, S. & Kapur, R. L. (1982) Impact of treatment intervention on the relationship between dimensions of clinical psychopathology, social dysfunction and burden on the family of psychiatric patients. British Journal of Psychiatry, 12, 651–658.Google Scholar
Pasamanick, B., Scarpitty, F. R. & Dinitz, S. (1967) Schizophrenics in the community. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.Google Scholar
Polak, P. R. & Kirby, M. W. (1976) A model to replace psychiatric hospitals. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 162, 13–22.Google Scholar
Polak, P. R., Kirby, M. W. & Deitchman, W. S. (1979) In New Directions for Mental Health Services, 1, 49–64.Google Scholar
Reynolds, I. & Hoult, J. E. (1984) The relatives of the mentally ill, a comparative trial of community oriented and hospital oriented psychiatric care. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 172, 480–489.Google Scholar
Scott, R. (1980) A family orientated psychiatric service to the London Borough of Barnet. Health Trends, 12, 65–67.Google Scholar
Stein, L. I. (1982) Community support systems for persons with chronic mental illness. New Directions for Mental Health Services, 14.Google Scholar
Stein, L. I. & Ganser, L. J. (1983) Wisconsin's system for funding mental health services. Unified health systems: Utopia unrealised (ed. by Talbott, J. A.). New Directions for Mental Health Services , 18, 25–32.Google Scholar
Stein, L. I. & Test, M. A. (1980) Alternative to mental hospital treatment: I. A conceptual model, treatment program and clinical evaluation. Archives of General Psychiatry, 37, 392–397.Google Scholar
Team for the Assessment of Psychiatric Services (TAPS) (1990) Better out than in? London: North East Thames Regional Health Authority.Google Scholar
Test, M. A. (1990) Theoretical and research bases of community care programmes. In Mental Health Care Delivery: Innovations, Impediments and Implementation (eds Marks, I. M. & Scott, R.), pp. 11–16, 254–256. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Thornicroft, G. & Breakey, W. (1991) The Costar Program. I: Improving patients' networks. British Journal of Psychiatry, 159, 245–249.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Turner, J. C. & Tenhoor, W. J. (1978) The NIMH support program: pilot approach to a needed social reform. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 4, 319–349.Google Scholar
Weissman, M. M., Paykel, E. S., Siegel, R. & Klerman, G. (1971) The social role performance of depressed women: comparisons with a normal group. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 41, 390–405.Google Scholar
Wing, J. K., Cooper, J. E. & Sartorius, N. (1974) The Description and Classification of Psychiatric Symptoms: an instruction manual for the PSE and Catego system. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Wing, J. K., & Sturt, E. (1978) The PSE-ID-Catego System: supplementary manual. London: MRC Social Psychiatry Unit.Google Scholar
Submit a response

eLetters

No eLetters have been published for this article.